On the review-aggregation website Rotten Tomatoes, the film has an approval rating of 43% based on 23 reviews, with an average rating of 5/10. Principal photography on the film began in mid-July 2016 in New Orleans.
In May 2016, Ari Sandel was set to direct the film from a script by John Whittington and Adam DeVine, while producers on the film are Adam Saunders of Footprint Features, Mason Novick of MXN Entertainment, with Mary Viola and McG of Wonderland Sound and Vision.
He also realizes that, having bonded with Carrie during his time travel adventures, he is meant to be with her. Following another conversation with Carrie, Noah recognizes that Avery does not love him and she is meant to be with Ethan. However, his friendship with Max has soured because he took the senior vice president position that Max was working towards, his job commitments prevent him from spending time with Avery, and Ethan is now distraught over Avery marrying someone else. When he returns to 2017, he and Avery live in a big house and are engaged. Noah gets a job at Max's company and presents himself in a more mature manner to Avery for his third attempt. Recognizing that Avery and Ethan are still attracted to each other, Noah has a conversation with Carrie and deduces that Avery is attracted to stable and dependable men. For his second attempt traveling back to 2014, Noah follows his friend Max's advice of being a rude alpha male and successfully beds Avery, but he develops a self-absorbed personality and when he returns to the present, his relationship with Avery is purely sexual. Noah uses his pre-existing knowledge of Avery to his advantage in his first attempt to win her over, but Avery and her roommate Carrie Grey suspect him of being a stalker, and he returns to a new version of 2017 where he and Avery do not know each other. Awakening in bed, Noah discovers the photo booth brought him back to the day they met and he resolves to change the events of the day to ensure he and Avery end up together. When he becomes intoxicated at Ethan and Avery's engagement party, Noah winds up in the photo booth he used with her on their first meeting and drunkenly operates it before falling asleep. Three years later, Noah remains distraught at not having been able to win her over.
Avery meets her fiancé, Ethan, the day after she and Noah met. Noah Ashby falls in love with Avery Martin after meeting her at a 2014 Halloween party, but she regards him as a friend.